[THS] Guardian: Autopsies reveal intensity of Israeli military force

[The Harder Stuff in news and commentary]

Gaza flotilla attack: Autopsies reveal intensity of Israeli military force

• Victims found with up to six gunshot wounds

• Israel 'about to lose a friend' warns Turkey's US envoy

Robert Booth, Harriet Sherwood in Gaza City and Justin Vela in Istanbul
guardian.co.uk

Friday 4 June 2010

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/ju ... sy-results


The autopsy results reveal the extent of force used by Israeli commandos aboard the
Mavi Marmara (pictured). Photograph: Reuters

The autopsy results released today by the Turkish authorities after the Israeli attack
on the Gaza flotilla reveal in chilling detail the intensity of the military force unleashed
on the multinational convoy.

Each of the nine victims on the Mavi Marmara in international waters off the coast of
Israel in the early hours of Monday morning was shot at least once and some five or
six times with 9mm rounds.

The results also reveal how close the fighting was. Dr Haluk Ince, chair of Turkey's
council of forensic medicine (ATK), said: "Approximately 20cm away was the closest.
In only one case was there only one entrance wound. The other eight have multiple
entrance wounds. [The man killed by a single shot] was shot just in the middle of the
forehead with a distant shot."

The details emerged as Turkey warned that it may reconsider its diplomatic ties with
Israel unless it receives an apology.

The deputy prime minister, Bulent Arinc, warned: "We may plan to reduce our
relations with Israel to a minimum."

Namid Tan, the ambassador to Washington, warned that Israel was "about to lose
[a] friend". He repeated calls for an independent investigation of the raid and end its
blockade against Gaza.

Asked if Turkey might break off relations, he said: "We don't want this to go to that
point." But he added: "The government might be forced to take such an action."

Speaking at the funeral of the youngest activist, prime minister Tayyip Erdogan
accused Israel of betraying its religion. "You killed 19-year-old Furkan Dogan brutally.
Which faith, which holy book can be an excuse for killing him?" he asked.

According to the scientists at the ATK, Dogan, who held US and Turkish citizenship
was shot five times – from close range in the right side of his nose, in the back of the
head, in the back and twice in the left leg.

The oldest victim was 60-year-old Ibrahim Bilgen, a Turkish politician, engineer and
activist who was married with six children. He had been shot once in the right
temple, once in the right side of his chest, once in the back and once in the hip.

Cetin Topcuotlu, a 54-year old former Taekwondo champion who worked as a coach
for the Turkish national team, was shot three times – once in the back of his head,
once in his hip and once in his belly. His wife, Cigden, who was with him on the Mavi
Marmara said at his funeral on Thursday she would take part in further flotillas to
Gaza with her son.

The detail of the wounds came as yet more survivors returned to the UK and gave
their account of the attacks.

In a hastily arranged press conference in central Londonshortly after his Turkish
airlines plane touched down at Heathrow, Ismail Patel, the 47-year-old chairman of
the Friends of al-Aqsa, condemned what he called "the cold-blooded murder and
killing of our colleagues". He said: "These deaths were avoidable and I lay the blame
squarely with the Israelis."

Israel has previously said its troops had been left with no choice after they came
under attack from activists armed with knives and iron bars when they were dropped
by helicopter on to the ship.

Patel claimed that as soon as the Israeli Defence Force helicopter appeared above
the Mavi Marmara, "it started using immediately live ammunition" without any
warning being issued.

After the first victim fell the white flag was raised, he said, but Israeli forces
continued firing. "I think the Israeli soldiers were shooting to kill because most of the
people who died were shot in the top part of their bodies," he said. He believed that
later victims were injured in their legs after a "tactical move" by the commandos to
wound rather then kill.

Alex Harrison, a Free Gaza activist who was on the smaller Challenger yacht, which
was crewed mainly by women, said the Israelis used rubber bullets, sound bombs
and tasers against them.

"Two women were hooded, they had their eyes taped," she said, describing how the
yacht was quickly overwhelmed. "We stood and tried to obstruct the armed, masked
men and maintained no other defence and still they used violence."

Harrison, 32, from Islington, north London, also witnessed the Mavi Marmara being
stormed from above by helicopter and said the Israelis started firing before their
troops touched down on the boat.

"I have seen some selective footage that the Israelis have chosen to put out
suggesting that we responded with violence," she said. "You must remember that
these are unarmed civilians on their own boat in the middle of the Mediterranean.
People picked up what they could to defend themselves against armed, masked
commandos who were shooting."

The violence was "initiated by the Israelis on a massive scale," she said, adding she
was pleased her colleagues on the Rachel Corrie, an Irish vessel, were continuing to
Gaza this weekend.

"I am thrilled they are going," she said. "They know exactly what risks they face.
They are doing what our government's haven't and I thank them."

Both Harrison and Patel criticised the British authorities for failing to provide sufficient
consular assistance while the activists were detained in an Israeli prison in Beersheva.

Patel said he was not visited by anyone from the British mission and Harrison said the
consul told her that Israeli officials had prevented him visiting captured Britons.

"I did see the British consul," Harrison said. "He told me that he had sitting outside
the prison all day ... asking for access and not been given it. I see that as an insult
from Israel to the British, that they were denying the British consul the right that
citizens have. I also see it as a sign that the British don't have the strength to stand
up to Israel."

Foreign Secretary William Hague confirmed that a total of 34 of the activists on the
aid flotilla were British, with all but two of them having been sent to Turkey by the
Israeli authorities.

In Gaza City, the de facto Hamas prime minister, Ismail Haniyeh, told crowds of
worshippers at Friday prayers that Israel's blockade was in its final stages.

"Now not only Gazans speak of the blockade, but also the [UN] security council and
the international community. Everyone is demanding the siege be lifted."


The nine victims

Cengiz Alquyz, 42

Four gunshot wounds: back of head, right side of face, back, left leg


Ibrahim Bilgen, 60

Four gunshot wounds: right chest, back, right hip, right temple


Cegdet Kiliclar, 38

One gunshot wound: middle of forehead

Furkan Dogan

Five gunshot wounds: nose, back, back of head, left leg, left ankle


Sahri Yaldiz

Four gunshot wounds: left chest, left leg, right leg twice


Aliheyder Bengi

Six gunshot wounds: left chest, belly, right arm, right leg, left hand twice


Cetin Topcuoglu

Three gunshot wounds: back of head, left side, right belly


Cengiz Songur

One gunshot wound: front of neck


Necdet Yildirim

Two gunshot wounds: right shoulder, left back